We've never really played Alien Hominid, actually - I started it up once, was totally useless at it and never really played it again after that. I've been told that despite my impression, though, it's actually one of the best games on the PS2 and I should try to get into it again. (It just feels weird that it was done by Newgrounds, which I normally associate with dodgy anime games.)

I've started playing Diablo 2 twice and got about halfway through each time before being distracted by something else somehow - my brother used to be obsessed with it, though, and had several high-level characters on servers across the world.